Required efficiency
Required efficiency is a very loose term which in chromatography usually means the number of theoretical plates a column must have, when used with a defined stationary phase, mobile phase, temperature and flow rate (assumed to be the optimum flow rate) to separate a given pair of substances eluted at a specific capacity ratios and having a specific separation ratio. It might be guessed that the theoretical treatment of this problem is quite complex and the equation that gives the number of plates required also complex. However, by using the equation, and having calculated the number of plates that are required, the next challenge is to obtain them. If the distribution system, flow rate and temperature, has been defined, then there are only a few simple procedures left to control the number of theoretical plates in the column. There is linear relationship between the number of theoretical plates and the column length and, thus, the column length can be adjusted to provide the required number of theoretical plates. The number of theoretical plates in the column is (approximately) inversely proportional to the particle diameter and so the particle diameter can be reduced to produce more theoretical plates (reducing the column diameter will not change the column efficiency but reduce the loading capacity). The extent to which the particle size is reduced will be limited by the available pump pressure. The same discussion also applies to the capillary column, however, the column diameter replaces the particle diameter.
Author: RPW Scott
Book:The Thermodynamics of Chromatography
Section:Thermodynamics Other-Methods Chiral-Separations Column-Efficiency
nbsp;  
The Effect of Temperature and Solvent Composition on the Required Column Efficiency
Using the
values for the capacity ratios and separation ratios derived from equations
(47), (48) and (49) in equation (39) the efficiency necessary to ensure a
separation of (6s) for the two
enantiomers can be calculated over a range of temperatures and solvent
compositions.
Figure 22.
Graphs of Required Efficiency against Temperature for Each Solvent Composition
Curves
relating required efficiency against temperature for each solvent composition,
calculated in this manner, are shown in figure 22. As would be expected, the
minimum efficiency is required at the lowest temperature and lowest ethanol
concentration. As either the separation ratio and/or the capacity ratios
decrease, the necessary efficiency to achieve a separation increases (as
predicted by equation (39)). At one extreme
Thermodynamics Other-Methods Chiral-Separations Column-Efficiency
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Plate Theory and Extensions
Section:Plate-Theory Resolving-Power
.02, an efficiency of 360,000 theoretical would be
required if the (k') value was 0.5. GC Capillary columns can provide such
efficiencies but, in LC, such efficiencies would be extremely difficult and
costly to produce. It follows that the phase system should be chosen so that
the closest eluted solutes are not eluted at low (k') values. Less efficiency
will be needed and, thus, shorter columns and consequently, shorter analysis
times will be achieved. At (k') values that exceed 10, the requiredefficiency changes little as the capacity ratio increases. Thus, for fast
analyses, the phase system provide a large separation ratio, but the first peak
should elute at a (k') of 10 or more. The phase system should have high
selectivity and retentive capacity so that minimum efficiency is required and
the column can be as short as possible. 
Plate-Theory Resolving-Power
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Preparative Chromatography
Section:Preparative Loading-Capacity
column design. It is clear that increasing radius and length of the
column increases both the maximum sample volume and the maximum sample mass. It
is also seen that increasing the column length will also increase the column
efficiency (unless it is accompanied by an corresponding increase in the
particle diameter).
However,
increasing the column efficiency will have the opposite effect, as seen by
equation (1), it will reduce the maximum sample load. Consequently, if
the necessary efficiency to achieve the required separation has been obtained,
then if the column is lengthened to increase the loading capacity for optimum
performance, either the flow rate will need to be increased to reduce the
efficiency and thus maintain the maximum loading, or the particle size will
need to be increased to reduce the efficiency to its required value. However,
an increased flow rate will also reduce separation time and thus increase
sample throughput. Conversely, the alternative use of
Preparative Loading-Capacity
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Liquid Chromatography
Section:HPLC Applications
5 m. The mobile
phase consisted of 26.5% v/v of methanol, 16.5%v/v acetonitrile and 57.05v/v
of 0.1M ammonium acetate adjusted to a pH of 6.0 with glacial acetic acid and
the flow-rate was 2 ml/min. The column efficiency available at the optimum
velocity would be about 15,000 theoretical plates. The retention time of the
last peak is about 12 minutes (i.e., a retention volume of 24 ml). At a
flow rate of 2 ml/min., the mobile phase velocity will be well above the
optimum and so the maximum efficiency has not been realized. The general
technique used when there are more theoretical plates available than required
is to increase the flow rate until the separation required is just realized.
This procedure trades efficiency for time and allows the separation to be
achieved in the minimum time given the column and phase system that has been
chosen
HPLC Applications
Author: RPW Scott
Book:The Thermodynamics of Chromatography
Section:Thermodynamics Other-Methods Chiral-Separations Column-Length
product of the required efficiency (figure 22) and (Hmin) (figure 23) which is shown for
different temperatures and solvent compositions in figure 24. The dependence of
the minimum theoretical plates on temperature and solvent composition dominates
the magnitude of the product and, thus, the curves in figure 24 take a form
similar to those in figure 22. The higher the temperature and the stronger the
ethanol concentration, the smaller the magnitude of (k'). Thus, more
theoretical plates will be required to resolve the enantiomers and thus a
longer column will be necessary. At a temperature of 5˚C and at an ethanol
concentration of 5%v/v, the column need only be about 5 mm long(a length of
column that is impractical to pack and operate). Contemporary columns, shorter
that 2 cm are extremely difficult to operate efficiently.
Figure 24
The Minimum Column Length that will Produce the Required Efficiency
The minimum
column length that will provide the minimum
Thermodynamics Other-Methods Chiral-Separations Column-Length
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Dispersion in Chromatography Columns
Section:Dispersion Rate-Theory
' for the solute to achieve equilibrium at that
point in the column and the process of distribution could be considered as
incremental. This approach has been discussed in
Plate Theory and Extensions
.
Employing this
concept an equation for the elution curve can be easily obtained and, from that
basic equation, others can be developed that describe the various
properties of a chromatogram. Such equations have permitted the calculation of
efficiency, the number of theoretical plates required to achieve a specific
separation and among many applications, elucidate the function of the heat of
absorption detector.
The Plate
Theory, however, does little to explain how the efficiency of a column may be
changed or, what causes peak dispersion in a column in the first place. It does
not tell us how dispersion is related to column geometry, properties of the
packing, mobile phase flow-rate, or the physical properties of the distribution
system. Nevertheless, it was not so much
Dispersion Rate-Theory