Rate Theory
There are two basic theories applicable to chromatography, the Plate Theory and the Rate Theory. The Plate theory describes the mechanism of retention and gives an equation that allows the calculation of the retention volume of a solute and the column efficiency. The rate theory describes the process of peak dispersion (band spreading) and provides an equation that allows the calculation of the variance per unit length of a column (the height of the theoretical plate, HETP) in terms of the mobile phase velocity and other physical chemical properties of the solute and distribution system. In the development of the plate theory, a number of different peak dispersion processes are proposed and expressions are developed that describe the contribution of each process to the total variance of the eluted peak. The final equation gives an expression for the variance per unit length of the column. The processes proposed are eddy diffusion, longitudinal diffusion, resistance to mass transfer in the mobile phase and resistance to mass transfer in the stationary phase. The rate theory has been developed differently by a number of well established scientists in the field. This has resulted in a number of different equations; viz. The Van Deemter Equation, the Giddings Equation, the Huber Equation, the Horvath Equation and the Knox Equation. Each equation differs slightly from one another and are all developed from first principles except the Knox equation, which was developed from experimentally observed relationships and subsequently rationalized on a first principle basis. All the equations give a type of hyperbolic function that predicts a minimum plate height at an optimum velocity and, thus, a maximum efficiency. At normal operating velocities it has been demonstrated that the Van Deemter equation gives the best fit to experimental data.
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Dispersion in Chromatography Columns
Section:Dispersion Rate-Theory
little to explain how the efficiency of a column may be
changed or, what causes peak dispersion in a column in the first place. It does
not tell us how dispersion is related to column geometry, properties of the
packing, mobile phase flow-rate, or the physical properties of the distribution
system. Nevertheless, it was not so much the limitations of the Plate Theory
that provoked Van Deemter et al (2) (who were chemical engineers
and mathematicians) to develop, what is now termed the Rate Theory for
chromatographic dispersion, but more to explore an alternative mathematical
approach to explain the chromatographic process. Virtually all basic
chromatography theory evolved over the twenty five years between 1940 and 1965
and it was in the middle of this period that Van Deemter and his colleagues
presented their Rate Theory concept in (1956). Since that time, other Rate
Theories have been presented, together with accompanying dispersion equations
and in due course each will be
Dispersion Rate-Theory
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Plate Theory and Extensions
Section:Plate-Theory Derivation
The
chromatogram that depicts the elution of a solute is a graph relating the
concentration of the solute in the mobile phase leaving the column to elapsed
time. However, at a constant flow rate, the chromatogram will also relate the solute
concentration to the volume of mobile phase passed through the column. In
figure 1, is shown the elution of a single peak. The expression, f(v), is the
elution curve equation and this will be derived using the plate theory.
Figure 1. The Elution Curve of
a Single Peak
Once the
nature of f(v) identified,
then by differentiating f(v) and equating to zero, the position of the peak
maximum can be determined and an expression for the retention volume (Vr)
obtained. The expression for (Vr) will disclose those factors that control
solute retention.
The Plate Theory
The plate
theory needs to assume that the solute, during its passage through the column,
is always in equilibrium with the
Plate-Theory Derivation
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Dispersion in Chromatography Columns
Section:Dispersion Summation-of-Variances
The purpose of
the Rate Theory is to help understand the processes that cause dispersion in a
chromatographic column and to identify those properties of the chromatographic
system that control it. Such information will allow the best column to be
designed to effect a given separation in the most efficient way. However,
before discussing the Rate Theory some basic concepts must be introduced
and illustrated.
The Summation of Variances
The width of
the band of an eluted solute relative to its proximity to
Dispersion Summation-of-Variances
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Dispersion in Chromatography Columns
Section:Dispersion Alternative-Axes
;
The ratio, (), (the column length divided by
the number of theoretical plates in the column) has, for obvious reasons,
become termed the Height Equivalent to the Theoretical
Plate (HETP) and has been given the symbol (H). However, it is seen that
(H) is numerically equal to, , which is, in fact, the variance per
unit length of the column. Thus, the function, , is the variance that
the Rate Theory will provide an explicit equation to define and can be
experimentally calculated for any column from its length and column efficiency.
It follows that the equations that give a value for, (H), the variance per unit
length of the column, have been termed HETP equations
Dispersion Alternative-Axes
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Dispersion in Chromatography Columns
Section:Dispersion Dispersion-Processes Diffusion Process
; ,
where (n) is
the variance of the Gaussian curve.
Now, (n) is
the volume variance of the Gaussian curve (i.e., ), then, by
comparison, (2Dmt) will be the length variance of the
concentration curve where (t) is the elapsed time. Consequently, if a
differential equation of the form is derived that
describes some form of dispersion that arises from a random diffusion process,
then the solution will be a Gaussian function and, more important from the
point of view of the Rate Theory, the Gaussian curve will have a variance given
by (2Dmt
Dispersion Dispersion-Processes Diffusion Process
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Dispersion in Chromatography Columns
Section:Dispersion Alternative-Axes
be identified, and an
expression for the variance arising from each dispersion process evaluated,
then the variance of the final band can be calculated from the sum of all the
individual variances. This is how the Rate Theory provides an equation for the
final variance of the peak leaving the column.
The Alternative Axes of a Chromatogram
An elution
curve of a chromatogram can be expressed using parameters other than the volume
flow of mobile phase as the independent variable. The Plate theory provides
an equation that expresses the retention and standard deviation of a peak in
terms volume flow of mobile phase. However, instead of using milliliters of
mobile phase, as the independent variable, solute concentration in the mobile
phase can be related, time, or distance traveled by the
solute band along the column and proportionally the same chromatogram will be
obtained. This is illustrated in figure (1
Dispersion Alternative-Axes