Gas Density Balance
The gas density balance was originally described in the early 1950s and was the first in-line gas chromatography detector to be invented. In its original form it consisted of a Wheatstone network of tubes drilled out of a high conductivity copper block. The net-work of tubes were self balancing and were so arranged that, in the center of the block, the carrier gas from the column passed up one tube and pure carrier gas flowed up another tube beside it. The two tubes were connected at the center through a cylindrical convection chamber about 2 cm in diameter and 3-4 mm wide. A looped heater was situated in the chamber and twin thermocouples consisting of two copper wires 0.001 in OD with 2 mm of constantan wire of the same diameter arc welded between them placed above the heater wires. It was arranged that the thermocouple junctions were situated about 2 mm from the heater wires and thus, with no solute present were heated by convection to the same temperature When a solute was present in one tube, due the increases in vapor density of the tube contents, a pressure difference developed across the joining tube. This resulted in a flow of gas across the convection chamber, displacing the convection currents away from one thermocouple onto the other. This resulted in a potential developing across the copper wires which was amplified and fed to suitable recording device. Because the detector responded to the vapor density of the solute, the device could also be used to determine the molecular weight of a solute. The sensitivity of the detector was about 5 x 10-7 g/ml. The detector did not become very popular because it was so difficult to make. In fact, this constructional difficulty helped to provoke the development of other detectors.
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Gas Chromatography Detectors
Section:GC-Detectors Early-GC-Detectors Gas-Density-Balance
, was also invented by James and Martin but, for some
reason it seems, was never formally reported in the literature. Its
description, however, did appear in a review by A. T. James [5] and a detailed
explanation of the function described by Munday and Primavesi [6].
The Gas Density Balance
The gas density balance was a very complicated
and ingenious device and, incidentally, the modern 'socalled' gas density
bridge bears little or no resemblance to the original design. A diagram of the
gas density balance is shown in figure 7. The detector consisted of a compact
Wheatstone network of capillary tubes, drilled out of a high conductivity
copper block. The reference flow of mobile phase and the eluent from the column
entered at two opposing junctions of the bridge arms (the center of tube (C))
such that the eluent was contained in one vertical arm (C) and the pure mobile
phase in a parallel vertical arms (A) and (B).
Figure 7 The Martin Gas Density Bridge
GC-Detectors Early-GC-Detectors Gas-Density-Balance
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Gas Chromatography Detectors
Section:GC-Detectors Simple-Gas-Density-Balance
The Simple Gas Density Balance
The original gas density balance has already
been described. It was complicated, difficult to fabricate and its manufacture
was notacommercialsuccess. Intheearlydays of chromatography
GOW-MAC developed some elegantly designed filaments for use in the construction
of katharometers, which, in due course, were used in many other manufacturer's
katharometer products. These sensing filaments were rugged and highly reliable
and were used by GOWMAC to emulate Martin's density balance in a simple form.
A diagram of the GOW-MAC gas density balance is shown in figure 15. The sensor
consists of a pneumatic bridge of tubes containing three vertical tubes all
connected by horizontal tubes at the top and the bottom. Pure carrier gas
enters the center of the right hand vertical tube and splits into two streams
one passing along the lower horizontal tube and the other along the upper
horizontal tube. The eluent from the column enters the center of the middle
tube and
GC-Detectors Simple-Gas-Density-Balance
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Gas Chromatography
Section:YES Modern-GC
The gas
density balance, was the first detector with a truly catholic response that was
linearly related to the vapor density of the solute and consequently its
molecular weight. The gas density balance had a maximum sensitivity (minimum detectable concentration) of about 10-6
g/ml at a signal to noise ratio of two. This detector inspired the invention of
a wide range of detectors over the next decade providing both higher
sensitivity and selective response.
The Modern Gas Chromatograph
The modern gas
chromatograph is a fairly complex instrument mostly computer controlled. The
samples are mechanically injected, the analytical results are automatically
calculated and the results printed out, together with the pertinent operating
conditions in a standard format. However, the instrument has evolved over many
years although the majority of the added devices and techniques were suggested
or describe in the first three international symposia on gas
YES Modern-GC
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Gas Chromatography
Section:YES Introduction
in a vapor jacket. Initially, the detector was situated at the
base of the column and consisted of the automatic titrating device, the
separation was presented as a chromatogram in the form of a series of steps,
the height of each step being proportional to the mass of solute eluted. The
apparatus was successfully used to separate some fatty acids, but the limited
capability of the device to sense only ionic material motivated Martin to
develop a more versatile detector, the Gas Density Balance
YES Introduction
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Gas Chromatography Detectors
Section:GC-Detectors Flame-Ionization
a differential flow
through the horizontal tubes with a consequent change in the output from the sensors.
As the differential flow will be proportional to the pressure difference
between the right-hand column of pure carrier gas and the center column full of
vapor, the output from the sensor filaments will be proportional to the vapor
density of the solute and consequently be related to the molecular weight. In
fact with a second detector that measured the concentration of the solute, the
gas density balance can be used to determine molecular weight of an eluted
solute. This device has about the same sensitivity and linearity as the
katharometer but, unfortunately, is no longer commercially available. It was
one of the very few simple and inexpensive methods available for measuring the molecular weight of an eluted
solute.
The Flame Ionization detector
Without doubt, the Flame Ionization Detector (FID) is the most useful GC detector
available and by far that most
GC-Detectors Flame-Ionization
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Gas Chromatography Detectors
Section:GC-Detectors Simple-Gas-Density-Balance
Courtesy of GOW-MAC
Figure
15. The GOW-MAC Gas Density Balance
GC-Detectors Simple-Gas-Density-Balance