Exclusion
Exclusion chromatography is a separation technique that resolves mixtures of substances on the basis of molecular size. The stationary phase is chosen to have pores with a narrow range of pore diameters. The smaller molecules enter most of the pore and, thus, are exposed to the majority of the stationary phase (or static mobile phase) and are, thus, retained. Large molecules, are excluded from most of the stationary phase and static mobile phase (hence the term exclusion chromatography) and are eluted rapidly. Thus, solutes are eluted in order of the reduced molecular size, the largest are eluted first the smallest last. It should be pointed out, that all silica based stationary phases are porous and, thus, even when a solute is retained largely by interactive forces, its retention will also be affected by the exclusion properties of the solid phase. Consequently, retention will be the result of a combination of molecular interaction and exclusion. Retention by exclusion results from the standard entropy contribution to the standard energy and, if exclusion is the major factor controlling retention, the separation is said to be entropically driven.
Author: RPW Scott
Book:The Mechanism of Chromatographic Retention
Section:Retention Exclusion Silica-Exclusion-Properties
give a mixed gel with definitive exclusion properties for specific separations.
The exclusion
properties of a silica gel cannot be obtained with sufficient accuracy for
chromatographic use from nitrogen adsorption data or mercury porosity tests. It
is necessary to determine the range of pore diameters and pore volume of a
silica gel by a special experimental procedure that is designed to obtain
accurate retention volume measurements for solutes eluted in relatively small
elution volumes. In exclusion chromatography, all the peaks will be contained
in a mobile phase volume equivalent to that of the total pore volume of the
column. Consequently, the column volume itself must be large and a column 25 cm
long and 4.6 mm I.D. is a practical size to obtain results having adequate
accuracy. The sample volume used should be 0.5 to 1.0 ml in volume and the detector should have a low sensor volume (cf.
2-4 ml). A mobile phase that would be
suitable for exclusion measurements with silica gel
Retention Exclusion Silica-Exclusion-Properties
Author: RPW Scott
Book:The Mechanism of Chromatographic Retention
Section:Retention Exclusion Blended-Silica
by blending different silica gels. Northrop et al (17) examined
the exclusion properties of a number of silica gels all having a particle size
of 10m They choose two specific gels,
one with a mean pore diameter of 80 and the other with a mean pore diameter of
500 and blended them to provide an exclusion packing that had a molecular
weight range extending from 100 to about 1,000,000. The packing was intended
for use in the separation of high molecular weight materials of biological
origin. The exclusion curves obtained for the two silica gels and the blend
having 38% 80 silica and 62% 500
silica are shown in figure 31.
Figure 31.
Graph of Exclusion Volume against Molecular Weight
Retention Exclusion Blended-Silica
Author: RPW Scott
Book:The Mechanism of Chromatographic Retention
Section:Retention Chromatographic-Interactions
the
latter in exclusion chromatography. In practice, it is rare that either
procedure is exclusive in any given separation as both retentive processes are
usually present to some extent, particularly in liquid chromatography (LC).
Retention in gas chromatography (GC), using coated open tubes, is, perhaps, the
exception, as, in this distribution system, exclusion processes (aside from
chiral phases) are normally absent and, consequently, retention control is
purely interactive. Interaction and exclusion processes, when they do occur
together, act independently. Although, together they determine overall the
retention of a solute, the exclusion properties of a stationary phase do not
effect the magnitude of any of its interactive properties.
The mechanisms
of retention have been discussed briefly in Book 1, but will now be considered
in greater detail. Although both retention
processes (interaction and exclusion) are usually active, because they
contribute to retention
Retention Chromatographic-Interactions
Author: RPW Scott
Book:The Mechanism of Chromatographic Retention
Section:Retention Exclusion Silica-Gel-Preparation
Retention and Exclusion
All stationary
phases based on silica gel exhibit exclusion properties. Polystyrene stationary phases are broadly
similar in physical form but their exclusion properties tend to be less
significant than those of silica gel. The exclusion properties of silica gel
arise from its method of formation and so the processes involved will help
reveal the physical nature of the gel.
Silica gel is
an amorphous, highly porous, partially hydrated form of silica made from the two most
Retention Exclusion Silica-Gel-Preparation
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Principles and Practice of Chromatography
Section:Principles Available-Stationary-Phase Exclusion
phase or supporting material contains pores
of size commensurate with those of the solute molecules, exclusion will
still partly control retention. This is because the larger molecules will
interact with less stationary phase and be eluted relatively faster than
if they had interacted with the same amount of stationary phase as the smaller
molecules. The two most common exclusion media used in
LC are silica gel and macroporous polystyrene divinylbenzene resins. Figure 19 shows an exclusion chromatogram of a series of molecular weight
standards obtained on silica gel.
The column
length was 50 cm and the mobile phase tetrahydrofuran (THF). The THF would be
strongly adsorbed on the silica surface and thus the solutes would be
distributed between pure THF in the mobile phase and THF on the surface of the
silica. As a consequence, the interactions are virtually identical in the two
phases and the retention was determined almost exclusively by
Principles Available-Stationary-Phase Exclusion
Author: RPW Scott
Book:Plate Theory and Extensions
Section:Plate-Theory Experimental-Dead-Volume
nbsp;
Courtesy of the Analyst (ref.11)
Figure 8.
Graph of Retention Volume of n-Alkanes against Carbon Number
In figure 8,
all the points lie on the same straight line, irrespective of the operating
temperature and, thus, the enthalpy term (see
The Thermodynamics of Chromatography
) is close to zero and the
solutes are not retained by differential molecular forces. Consequently, the
retention of the hydrocarbon solutes is solely due to exclusion.. It is clear
that the exclusion effect is significant and, by extrapolating to a carbon
number of zero, the total volume of mobile phase in the column is obtained.
In this case,
the total interstitial volume plus the total pore volume is
about 2.9 ml.
This value
agrees well with the data for the retention of water and methanol.
The problems
associated with exclusion and dead volume measurement cannot be avoided but
they can be minimized.
Probably the best
Plate-Theory Experimental-Dead-Volume